Qualitative methods
- research data collected without limitations
- the researcher doesn’t define variables before the research
- patterns are searching during the study
- the output of the qualitative study is the new hypotheses or theory
- it should be mentioned on how our informants were taken into the study
Qualitative Approach
- Phenomena are being explored entirely with all consequences
- It is a detail-oriented process in a small amount of objects
- The main goal is exploration and the results can not be generalized
- Results are easily influenced by the researcher’s personality
Research design
- Practical advise:
- First step – narrowing the topic
- Flow chart
- Defining a puzzle
- Approaching lens
- Why X developed (developing question)
- How x works (mechanistic question)
- Which characteristics have people who do (causality)
Validity
- Qualitative research uses “triangualtion” as a way how to provide validity
- In carthography is this word used for three points which placement is known
- The meaning is to get more independent sources for verification our results
- Usually, it means to use more qualitative method to create a set of stability conditions
The third variable
- This method confines reductionism
- I want to avoid to explicate a complex of social issues or areas just with a simple “one-reason” explanation
Typology
- Case study – it is a detail-oriented study which seeks for reasons, factors, effects processes or experiences predeceeds to the result (eg. drug addiction)
- Study of community -marked as sociography
- Analysis of patterns in main aspect of the community
- Urban sociology
- https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-097086-8.32024-4
- Study of social groups – analyses realtionships
- Study of institutions – similar focus
Case study
- The basic idea of a case study is that one case can be studied in detail, using whatever methods seem appropriate
- The case – can be a single unit (a person, a community..)
- This is used for a purely descriptive approach
Typology – goals
- Intrinsic study – a researcher is engaged in the topic personally (not well known phenomenon)
- Instrumental cases – the results are aiming behind the single case – generalization
- Collective study – exploring more phenomena together – the goal is to find connections and relationships between them
Typology purpose
- Exploratory studies – seeks for the structure of a case which is not known
- Explanatory study – looks for reason chains and explain the whole process (reason analysis)
- Descriptive study – generates a complete descriptions of a phenomenon
- Evaluation study – the goal can be description, explanation or exploration in order to assign an intervention program
Approaches
- Phenomenological (hermeneutic) – the aim is to get access to a private wolrd of an object
- Grounded theory (Glaser & Strauss) – It uses systematic technics and methods to create a new theory (middle range theory)
- Ethnography – is based on observing everyday life and activities – The aim is to gain a holistic view of a specified group or community
- Biographic research – Let us say that it is a specific type of a case study – The Polish Peasant in Europe and America
- Action research – is based on two equivalent subjects – a researcher and “an observed”
- Critical research – is similar as action research but the goal is to change some aspects of the recent reality
- Historical research – psychohistory (Lloyd de Mause) – psychological motivations of historical events
- History of childhood and psychobiography
- and group-psychohistory
Analysis of documents
- Documents analysis (Hendl 2016)
- Non-reactive collection of data
- analysis of newspapers or records of talks or diaries, books, paintings, posters, movies, photographs.
- It means all the footprints of human existence
- Reliability: eg. official document is more reliable than newspapers
Collecting data
Methods of collecting data
- Interviews
- Focus Groups
- Naturally Occurring Data
- Observation
Interviews
- In qualitative research is commonly used unstructured interviews
- A free-flowing conversational style is adopted
- Respondents are encouraged to raise issues not originally included in the schedule
- Biographical interviews aim at the elicitation of personal stories with minimum researcher prompting
- Semi-structured interviews are most common
Focus Groups
- They were originally developed in market research
- Are used in research projects that involve previously unexamined topics
- Focus groups provide a context which allows for the development of argumentation adn counterargumantation and for the exploration of the interactional mechanisms involved in sense making
- Used for maginalized voices
Naturally occuring data
- Is not influenced or distorted by the researcher’s intention
- This includes a range of texts and interactions produced in the course of everyday life
- It includes archival documents, television programs, internet materials, official institutional archival data or naturally occuring conversations (therapy sessions, telephone calls recorded by service providers) also visuals photos etc
Observation
- Different types of observation are constructed on the basis of criteria if the researchers intervene in the pheomenon of study or interact with reserach participants
- Structured observation refers to a situation where the researcher creates the context where a behavior can occur
- Participant observation refers to a form of systematic observation whereby the observer interacts with the people being observed.
Data analysis
- Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis IPA
- Grounded Theory – GT
- Narative Analysis
- Discurisive Methods
- Conversation Analysis
- Rhetorical Analysis
- Thematic Analysis
Interpretative phenomenological analysis – IPA
- The researcher explores experience of one single person (or an unit)
- Lived experience – is a key term in this type of analysis
- The most important is to stick with the perspective of the informant
- Double hermeneutics – means to merge the informant’s experience with the reseracher’s personality added during an analysis
IPA – goals
- The main goal of IPA is to formulate topics which define the essence of the explored phenomenon
- A process of analysis starts with the first case (interview)
- Develooping of insider’s perspective
- Coding fieldnotes: semantic, similarities vs differencies, summarizing, paraphrasing, associations
IPA – developing a topic
- During the analysis are rising new topics
- Searching for coincidences across the topics
- Some topics work as a magnet, they attract similar topics
- Some topics are superior to each other and the others become one
- Creating a structure of topics and naming these classes
IPA what to notice
- A degree of abstraction
- Integration – related topics under one umbrella
- Polarization – differences between topics
- Contextualization -identifying narrative elements
- Frequence of occurences
- Functions -finding piositive or negative conotations
- Restructuralisation of topics
Grounded theory
- Is a research method which is grounded in data that has been systematically collected and analysed (Glaser & Strauss)
- Features
- Data collection and analysis occur sumultaneously
- Categories and codes developed from data
- Abstract categories constructed inductively
- Social processes discovered in the data
- Analytical memos used between coding and writing
- Categories integrated into a theoretical framework
- The foundation is clearly defining a question
- This is focused on a process or stges of a phenomenon
- The aim is to describe rules of this process
- Glaser – claims that the question should be stated after a contact with the terrain
- It means to talk about the topic with future participants before the research design is done
Theoretical sensitivity
- Researcher is able to develop a theory that is grounded theoretically dense and cohesive
- It concerns the resarcher being able to give meaning to data, understand what the data says
- And researcher is able to separate out what is relevant and what is not
GT – research process
- Step 1 – research question
- Step 2 – collecting data
- Step 3 creating concepts
- Step 4 – searching for theoretical relationships between concepts
- Step 5 . a choice of the central concepts and formulation a theory
GT Analysis – coding
- “open coding” – the aim is to conceptualize dat – creating essential terms
- concepts and key phares as identified and highligheted moved into subcategories
- this breaks the data down into conceptual components
- the researcher can start to theorise or reflect on the content and understanding sense of the data
- the data form each participant will be constantly compared for similarities
- axial coding – at this stage relationships are identified between the categories and connections identified
- selective coding: this involves identifying the core category and methodically relating it to other categories. Categories are then integrated together and GT identified
GT – Core Category
- Is the chief pheonomena around which the categories are built.
- Theory is generated around a core category
- The core category should account for the variation found in the data, the categories will relato to it in some way.
Narrative analysis
- Refers to a cluster of analytic methods for interpreting texts or visual data that have a storied form
- A common assumption of narrative method is:
- People tell stories to help organize information and make sense of their lives
- Their storied accounts are functional and purposeful
- Differemt approaches of NA are categorized whether they focus on structure or content of narratives.
Discursive Methods
- Usually called discourse analysis
- The key of the different method is the recognition of the vital role of discourse in social life
- An approach to language as social practice instead of a pathway to inner cognitive entities (social constructionism)
- The term discourse is used to refer to virtually any language use and considered interpreattive repertoires (recurrently used units of content)
Conversational analysis
- CA refers to a specific approach to the analysis of interaction (Harvey Sacks)
- CA is interested to understand social order by focusing analytically on the sequence of talk in interaction
- And on the ways how participants organize mundane conversation
Thematic analysis
- A definition what thematic analysis means is quite inconsistent
- Mainly, it involves coding of qualitative data into clusters of similar entities or conceptual categories
- Identifiacation of consistent patterns and relationships between themes
Rhetorical analysis
- Interest in rhetoric also arose as part of discursive turn
- Key text constitutes Arguing and Thinking (Billig 1987)
- This helps deeper understanding of how to approach analytically context and content in qualitative research by advocating the need to consider the rhetorical relation between topics (as units of analysis)